What the Arkansas PBM Ruling Means for the Industry

ProCare Rx Team • August 5, 2025

When Courts and Care Collide: What the Arkansas PBM Ruling Means for the Industry

A recent court decision in Arkansas has once again put pharmacy benefit managers (PBMs) under the spotlight. A federal judge ruled to block an Arkansas law that would have prevented PBMs from owning pharmacies. The reason? The judge said the law likely conflicts with federal rules.


To understand why this matters, it helps to take a step back.


PBMs help employers and health plans manage prescription drug benefits. That includes negotiating drug prices, building pharmacy networks, and setting reimbursement rates. In some cases, PBMs also own their own pharmacies, something critics say creates a conflict of interest.


Arkansas lawmakers tried to stop that by passing a law in 2023 that banned PBMs from owning pharmacies or making pharmacy referrals. Several PBMs pushed back, and the case ended up in court. In July 2025, a federal judge sided with the PBMs, saying the state law could not override federal regulations under Medicare Part D.


But that was not the only PBM headline in Arkansas. Just days before, state officials filed a major lawsuit against several of the largest PBMs, claiming they drove up costs and hurt local pharmacies by setting unfair reimbursement rates.


So, what does this mean for the rest of us?


It is a reminder that the pharmacy benefits world is changing fast. Employers and plan sponsors need PBM partners who do more than just follow the rules. They need partners who lead with transparency.


At ProCare Rx, transparency is not just a feature. It is a foundation. We give plan sponsors full visibility into pricing, contracts, and claims. That means no hidden fees. No backdoor deals. And no confusion about where your dollars go.


In moments like these, when laws are challenged and lawsuits are filed, clarity matters more than ever. When employers and health plans know exactly how their pharmacy dollars are being spent, they can make better decisions for their members.



Regulations may change. But our commitment to clear, ethical, and compliant service never will.


About ProCare Rx
ProCare Rx is a privately held, independent pharmacy benefit manager (PBM) that has empowered healthcare and self-insured organizations since 1988. We provide fully integrated, in-house solutions—including claims adjudication, clinical program design, pharmacy network access, cost containment, and data analytics—all supported in the U.S. Our flexible, transparent model serves self-insured employers, third-party administrators (TPA), brokers, health plans, health systems, managed care organizations (MCO), unions, workers’ compensation programs, Medicare, Medicaid, hospices, and other PBMs. With a proprietary technology platform, commitment to ethical operations, and a focus on lowest net cost, ProCare Rx delivers long-term value, clinical performance, and trusted pharmacy benefit partnerships.

Media Contact:
Marc Cohen, VP, Marketing and Sales
marketing@ProCareRx.com

By ProCare Rx Team October 1, 2025
Drug costs continue to surge, regulatory winds are shifting, and employers are bracing for steeper expenses ahead. Now more than ever, your choice of PBM partner can be a major differentiator or a liability. Why This Moment Matters Cost growth expectations are steep. Employers are forecasting higher health care costs in 2026, with pharmacy spend as a central contributor. Some projections suggest pharmacy alone may rise by double digits next year, far outpacing general medical cost trends. Reform pressure is building. PBM practices are under increasing scrutiny. Policymakers, physician groups, and pharmacy organizations are pushing for reforms that would delink PBM profits from drug list prices, increase transparency, and ensure savings flow to plan sponsors and patients. PBMs themselves are already floating proposals to adjust their practices ahead of possible legislation. Regulation is becoming inconsistent and complex. While federal courts and Congress weigh in, states continue to pass new PBM laws. For multi-state employers, this means navigating a patchwork of rules that can be confusing, sometimes conflicting, and potentially at odds with fiduciary obligations. What to Look for in a PBM Partner Given this evolving landscape, employers should place extra emphasis on: Regulatory agility and compliance support Your PBM must help you navigate both federal and state-level requirements, protecting your plan against compliance risk. True cost transparency and incentive alignment Demand clarity on how your PBM is compensated. Incentives should be aligned with your plan, not tied to higher drug list prices or opaque rebate arrangements. Formulary integrity and clinical governance With expensive therapies hitting the market, your PBM should balance cost savings with clinical appropriateness, ensuring members receive the right drug, not just the cheapest option. Benefit design flexibility Rising costs require innovative plan designs such as specialty carve-outs, differential cost-sharing, or utilization management. Your PBM should be a partner in shaping these strategies, not a barrier. Member experience and adoption tools With members facing higher cost-sharing and more complex therapies, digital tools, adherence programs, and proactive engagement are essential for better outcomes. Proven performance and benchmarking In this climate, results matter. Your PBM should demonstrate measurable cost savings and clinical outcomes year over year, benchmarked against peers. The Bottom Line  Plan sponsors are entering a pivotal moment. The forces shaping pharmacy benefits include cost escalation, regulatory change, and clinical complexity. The status quo will not be enough. Choosing a PBM partner with regulatory foresight, aligned incentives, clinical integrity, and member-centric tools can help employers navigate this era, mitigate risk, and deliver sustainable value to their workforce. Sources Reuters – Pharma middlemen propose regulatory changes to avoid Trump administration rules Pharmacy Times – Pharmacy policy updates for September 2025 Bloomberg Law – Drug benefit compliance is a state-by-state test for sponsors NASPA – Over 100 pharmacy organizations urge PBM reform AMA – Advocacy update spotlight on PBMs Healthcare Dive – Employers expect 9% higher health costs in 2026 WorldatWork – Business Group on Health predicts 9% higher healthcare costs in 2026 PwC – Behind the numbers: Rising drug spend ProCare Rx PBM 101 video script
By ProCare Rx September 29, 2025
The world of pharma is evolving quickly, with direct-to-consumer (DTC) marketing and new patient engagement strategies changing how therapies are launched, prescribed, and accessed. Join John Drakulich for an insightful conversation on The New Pharma Playbook and what these shifts mean for employers, health plans, pharmacies, and patients. Hosted by ProCare Rx , this webinar takes a closer look at how DTC marketing influences prescribing behavior, patient decision-making, and overall drug costs, and how transparent PBM strategies can help plan sponsors navigate these challenges while prioritizing member care. Attendees will walk away with practical insights into how PBMs like ProCare Rx are driving innovation, improving access, and keeping costs under control in a changing marketplace.
By ProCare Rx Team September 5, 2025
PBM 101, Part 1: Why PBMs Matter for Employers
By ProCare Rx Team August 28, 2025
ProCare Rx appoints Marco Torelli as new SVP of Labor and Public Sector
By ProCare Rx Team August 27, 2025
ProCare Rx Names JD Edwards Senior Vice President of Sales
By ProCare Rx Team August 18, 2025
This appointment brings together multiple parts of the business under one umbrella to best serve our PBM clients and members, assuring that ClearSight transparency and Lowest Net Cost remains at the forefront of the innovative organization.
By ProCare Rx Team July 8, 2025
Prescription Drug Pricing: Will Policy Fix What Patients Feel?
By ProCare Rx Team June 2, 2025
Is Your PBM Working for You…Or Against You? How to Ask the Right Questions and Spot Red Flags in Pharmacy Benefit Management
By ProCare Rx May 20, 2025
ProCare Rx Announces New Executive Appointment and Launch of Technology Division to Drive Innovation and Growth The newly created role is expected to solidify leadership of the core technology infrastructure to both enhance support for current clients as well as developing additional value-added offerings to the marketplace.
By ProCare Rx Team May 19, 2025
Understanding the “Most Favored Nation” Drug Pricing Rule